Family Seeks Justice and Accountability After Fatal Surgery Error at Florida Hospital

By: Sam Watanuki | Published: Sep 05, 2024

William Bryan and his wife, Beverly, were visiting their vacation rental in Destin, Florida, in August 2023. What started as a relaxing getaway took a sharp turn when William experienced severe pain in his lower left abdomen.

Hoping for a quick resolution, they headed to Ascension Sacred Heart Emerald Coast Hospital, a decision that would lead to devastating consequences.

A Shocking Diagnosis

Upon arriving at the hospital, doctors suspected something was wrong with William’s spleen. Dr. Thomas Shaknovsky, the attending surgeon, recommended emergency surgery, insisting that any delay could lead to serious complications.

Advertisement
A doctor writing down information on a clipboard in his office

Source: Freepik

Despite his wife’s suggestion to return to Alabama for treatment, William agreed to the procedure under reported immense pressure from the medical staff.

A Life-Altering Decision

Beverly, a retired nurse, tried to convince Dr. Shaknovsky to allow her husband to be transferred home for surgery. However, the surgeon warned that moving William could result in fatal bleeding.

Advertisement
Two doctors in scrubs and mask look over information on a clipboard in a hospital

Source: Freepik

Reluctantly, the Bryans trusted the doctor’s advice, believing that immediate surgery was the safest option.

A Critical Mistake in the OR

On August 21, 2023, William underwent surgery, which was supposed to remove his spleen. However, during the procedure, Dr. Shaknovsky reportedly mistakenly removed William’s liver instead.

Advertisement
A doctor adjusts the settings on a machine in an operating room

Source: Freepik

This error resulted in catastrophic blood loss, and tragically, William died on the operating table. It wasn’t until after his death that the surgical team realized the fatal mistake.

Liver Labeled as Spleen

According to the family’s attorney, Joe Zarzaur, the surgeon even labeled William’s liver as his spleen. It wasn’t until the medical examiner performed an autopsy that the true scope of the error became clear.

Advertisement
A faceless doctor holds a digital illustration of a liver

Source: Freepik

The examiner confirmed that William’s spleen was still intact, and the “spleen” removed during surgery was actually his liver.

The Family’s Fight for Justice

In the wake of William’s death, Beverly Bryan and her family have vowed to seek justice. “I don’t want anyone else to die due to his incompetence at a hospital that should have known or knew he had previously made drastic, life-altering surgical mistakes,” Beverly said through her attorney.

A close-up of a small Lady Justice statue

Source: Tingey Injury Law Firm/Unsplash

The family has demanded a full investigation into the incident and is pursuing both a lawsuit and a criminal case.

Advertisement

Not the Surgeon’s First Mistake

Disturbingly, this wasn’t the first time Dr. Shaknovsky had been involved in a surgical error. Just a year earlier, he had removed a portion of a patient’s pancreas instead of performing an adrenal gland resection.

A man holds a pen and works on a document while surrounded by beakers with blue liquid

Source: ckstockphoto/Canva

That case was quietly settled, but it raised serious concerns about the surgeon’s competence.

Advertisement

Hospital Under Scrutiny

Ascension Sacred Heart Emerald Coast Hospital, where the surgery took place, is now under intense scrutiny. While the hospital has launched its own investigation, many are questioning how Dr. Shaknovsky was allowed to continue performing surgeries after previous incidents.

Lawsuit paperwork next to a book and a pen

Source: Adobe Stock

The family is also pushing for accountability from the hospital, hoping that changes will be made to prevent further tragedies.

Advertisement

Medical Examiner’s Findings

The medical examiner’s report added another layer to the case. While investigating the cause of William’s initial abdominal pain, the examiner discovered a small cyst on his spleen, which was likely the source of his discomfort.

A lawyer going over paperwork in her office

Source: Freepik

This further confirmed that the spleen had never been removed, highlighting the magnitude of the surgical error.

Advertisement

A Widow’s Heartbreaking Plea

Beverly Bryan, heartbroken by the loss of her husband, is now on a mission to ensure that no other family experiences the same tragedy.

The interior of a hospital room with a row of beds

Source: Gilberto Olimpio/Unsplash

“I know I’m not the only wife who’s lost her husband suddenly, but the loss of my Bill was exceptionally unnecessary and brutal,” she said.

Advertisement

Surgeon Scrubbed from Websites

Since the surgery, Dr. Shaknovsky has been removed from multiple medical websites, including North Walton Doctor’s Hospital, HCA Florida, and Ascension Sacred Heart.

A doctor wearing a stethoscope and a white lab coat on her phone.

Source: National Cancer Institute/Unsplash

His profile and photos have been scrubbed as the investigation unfolds—a move that has raised questions about the transparency and accountability of medical institutions.

Advertisement

The Legal Battle Ahead

As Beverly Bryan and her family prepare for a lengthy legal battle, their attorney is working through the pre-suit process, which could take six to nine months.

A lawyer pictured writing in his journal while he is seated at a wooden desk

Source: Freepik

The family is seeking both justice and accountability for William’s death, hoping to prevent Dr. Shaknovsky from ever practicing medicine again.

Advertisement