FDA Updates the Risk Level for Recall on Contaminated Ice Cream

By: Stephanie Bontorin | Published: Jul 12, 2024

More than 13,000 tubes of ice cream have been recalled due to possibly containing “foreign objects.”

Now, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has updated the risk level to a Class II recall in an attempt to warn the public and get all pints of ice cream returned to stores.

The Ice Cream Company

The recalled ice cream comes from a Utah-based brand called Casper’s Ice Cream Inc. The team voluntarily recalled one of the products after discovering that two tubs of ice cream contained rubber fragments.

Advertisement
A van painted with several ice cream pops

Source: @CVDaily/X

Although the recall was first issued on June 6 of this year, it has been updated this week by the U.S. FDA as a Class II recall.

Class II Recall

The FDA notes that a Class II recall is determined when a “situation in which use of or exposure to a violative product may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences or where the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.”

Advertisement
An FDA sign seen in front of a building.

Source: Public Domain/Wikimedia Commons

While this classification is not the most severe, it proves that the items in question have been contaminated to the point of harming public health.

The Product

The ice cream that is being recalled is the Red Button Vintage Creamery Cookie Dough Ice Cream with lot number 092-24-568 and UPC of 0 77865 01008 6.

Advertisement
Two boxes of ice cream sandwiches

Source: @FoodBev/X

The items were distributed in eight states including Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Nevada, Utah, and Wyoming.

Foreign Objects Pose Extreme Risks

The FDA notes that foreign or sharp objects in food can “cause traumatic injury including laceration and perforation of tissues of the mouth, tongue, throat, stomach and intestine as well as damage to the teeth and gums.”

Advertisement
Three ice cream cones in a small wooden stand

Source: @travelopulent/X

However, small particles that can become embedded into food during the manufacturing process rarely cause trauma or serious injury. Items that are enough to cause serious harm will be large enough for a consumer to see them and pick them out.

Rubber in Ice Cream

The recall notice included the information that while only two tubes of ice cream contained rubber, the company saw fit to recall all of the items off shelves to avoid any negative repercussions.

A girl scoops ice cream out of a tub into a white bowl

Source: @CVDaily/X

Casper’s Ice Cream Inc has not commented on how large the fragments were or how they got into the products.

Advertisement

What Is the Most Serious Classification of Recall?

Class II is only the second most serious classification of food recall.

A close-up of an emergency sign on a hospital building.

Source: Pixabay/Pexels

The most serious is Class I, which occurs when there is a “reasonable probability” that the use of, or exposure to, a product could “cause serious adverse health consequences or death.”

Advertisement

Food Recalls Usually Caused by Contamination

Most recalls are caused by a contamination found in the food or an issue with the packaging.

A chocolate bar on a dark surface

Source: Tamas Pap/Unsplash

Recently, there was a large recall of more than four million pounds of chocolate due to a possible salmonella outbreak.

Advertisement

Hard Plastics Found in Other Foods

Casper’s Ice Cream Inc. is not the only company to have had a recent recall due to foreign objects found in food.

A large bowl of potato salad made with small round potatoes, celery, red onions, and dill

Source: @smittenkitchen/X

Recently, H-E-B issued a voluntary recall on potato salad due to the presence of hard plastics in the food.

Advertisement

How Does Plastic End up in Food?

Because most food sold in grocery stores has been manufactured in plants and factories, the possibility of pieces of metal and plastic falling off machines and into the food can be high.

Cans of Sprite, Diet Coke, and Coca-Cola are offered for sale at a grocery store

Source: Scott Olson/Getty Images

The issue can happen to even the most established companies. In January of this year, Coca-Cola was forced to recall thousands of cans of Diet Coke, Sprite, and Fanta Orange after discovering “foreign material” inside several cans.

Advertisement

Packaging Can Also Be Tampered

Along with the food itself, many recalls are issued because there is a defect in the way that the packaging works or if the packaging could increase the risk of bacteria growth.

Three large bottles of cooking oil

Source: @GetWhiskedAway/X

In April, a company called Primal Kitchen had to recall over 2,000 bottles of cooking oil spray because the packaging was leaking. Often, the packaging issues pose no threat to the public but it can’t be sold.

Advertisement

What To Do If You Bought the Ice Ceam?

If you find that you have purchased any of the cookie dough ice cream, you can simply return it to the store where it was purchased.

A girl holding a chocolate ice cream cone with sprinkles

Source: Jenny Smith/Unsplash

Usually, you will not need a receipt, as the grocery stores and companies will be aware of the recall.

Advertisement